Skip to content
This platform is available in test mode and should not be referenced as an authoritative source of any requirements. Please refer to the original PDF of the CCP Assessment Framework until further notice.
8.5

Investment analysis

  1. Where a carbon-crediting programA standard-setting program that registers mitigation activities and issues carbon credits. allows use of investment analysis to demonstrate additionality, it shall require all of the following:
    1. a suitable financial indicator, such as the net present value (NPV) or internal rate of return (IRR), to be used in the calculation;
    2. the calculation of the financial indicator to include all relevant costs (CAPEX, OPEX) and all revenues, including subsidies or official development aid, where applicable;
    3. the assumptions, data and conclusions in the investment analysis to be:
      1. transparently documented in the documentation submitted for registration; 14
      2. appropriately justified and substantiated by evidence; AND
      3. consistent with information presented to the company’s decisionPer the Assessment Procedure, a decision of the Governing Board of the ICVCM that includes supporting rationale.-making management and investors/lenders;
    4. that all parameters and assumptions used in the analysis are internally consistent (i.e., cash flows shall be expressed in either real or nominal terms consistently, and the calculation shall be consistent with the indicator used, such as project IRR or equity IRR);
    5. in case of the benchmark analysis, that the financial benchmark used is consistent with the weighted average cost of capital (or the cost of equity, as applicable) that is commonly applicable to the country, sector and type of mitigation activityAn activity that reduces anthropogenic emissions of a GHG or enhances removals by sinks relative to GHG emissions or removals in the activity’s baseline scenario and seeks registration and issuance of carbon credits under a carbon-crediting program. The term refers to activities that may be implemented at different scales, including projects, programmatic approaches, policies, jurisdictional REDD+ programs, and other interventions. They may also be implemented at one or more sites.;
    6. in case of the benchmark analysis, that additionality is demonstrated if the analysis shows that:
      1. the mitigation activity would not meet the required financial benchmark without carbon creditA tradeable intangible instrument that is issued by a carbon-crediting program, representing a GHG emission reduction to, or removal from, the atmosphere equivalent to one metric tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent. This is calculated as the difference in GHG emissions or removals from a baseline scenario to the emissions or removals occurring under the mitigation activity, and any adjustments for leakage. The carbon credit is uniquely serialised, issued, tracked and retired or administratively cancelled by means of an electronic registry operated by an administrative body, such as a carbon-crediting program. revenues; AND
      2. the economic performance of the mitigation activity increases decisively through carbon credit revenues; AND
      3. carbon credit revenues can raise the economic performance at or above the required financial benchmark;
    7. that the period of assessment shall reflect the period of expected operation of the underlying mitigation activity or shall be a period of at least ten years and include the value of the assets at the end of the assessment period;
    8. in case of the investment comparison analysis:
      1. that the alternative scenarios considered are mutually exclusive and provide the same type of products or service levels as the mitigation activity, where applicable;
      2. that additionality is demonstrated if the analysis shows that the mitigation activity would not be the economically most attractive scenario in absence of carbon credits;
    9. that a sensitivity analysis shall be conducted to show whether the conclusion regarding the financial attractiveness is robust to reasonable variation in the critical assumptions;
    10. that all elements of the investment analysis are assessed as part of the validationThe process of independent, third-party evaluation of a mitigation activity requesting registration under a carbon-crediting program by an accredited Validation and Verification Body (VVB) against the program provisions of the applicable carbon-crediting program. by a VVB and/or the carbon-crediting program.
  2. Where a carbon-crediting program considers that its alternative additionality approaches meet the same threshold of additionality as achieved by the requirements above in relation to one or more Categories it may, per section 3 of the Assessment Procedure, submit an explanation of such and all relevant provisions to the ICVCM and shall make such explanation publicly available.

Footnotes

  1. 14

    Note criteria 3.1 a) and b) in relation to information being made publicly available subject to confidentiality and proprietary, privacy and data protection restrictions.

    ↩

Instruments

No instruments have been issued on this item yet.