Skip to content
This platform is available in test mode and should not be referenced as an authoritative source of any requirements. Please refer to the original PDF of the CCP Assessment Framework until further notice.
8.6

Barrier analysis

  1. Where a carbon-crediting programA standard-setting program that registers mitigation activities and issues carbon credits. allows the use of barrier analysis to demonstrate additionality, it shall require all of the following:
    1. that the types of barriers that may be considered are limited to the following:
      1. financial barriers (e.g., loans or other forms of financing are not accessible for the type of mitigation activityAn activity that reduces anthropogenic emissions of a GHG or enhances removals by sinks relative to GHG emissions or removals in the activity’s baseline scenario and seeks registration and issuance of carbon credits under a carbon-crediting program. The term refers to activities that may be implemented at different scales, including projects, programmatic approaches, policies, jurisdictional REDD+ programs, and other interventions. They may also be implemented at one or more sites. and country due to financier’s assessment of risks);
      2. institutional barriers (e.g., the investor not being the beneficiary of cost savings associated with the investment);
      3. information barriers (e.g., lack of awareness in households of the lifecycle costs of energy efficient appliances); OR
      4. other barriers specific to the mitigation activity and/or region where the mitigation activity is implemented if these barriers are explicitly identified and elaborated in the relevant quantification methodology or other program documentsThe documents adopted by carbon-crediting program that specify requirements, procedures and administrative and operational aspects of the carbon-crediting program. These documents include, but are not limited to, general carbon-crediting program standards, quantification methodologies, procedures, provisions, manuals, guidance and forms.;
    2. that the mitigation activity proponents shall be required:
      1. to identify specific barriers, and where possible, quantify such barriers; AND
      2. to provide verifiable evidence to demonstrate each identified barrier and verifiable evidence that the carbon creditA tradeable intangible instrument that is issued by a carbon-crediting program, representing a GHG emission reduction to, or removal from, the atmosphere equivalent to one metric tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent. This is calculated as the difference in GHG emissions or removals from a baseline scenario to the emissions or removals occurring under the mitigation activity, and any adjustments for leakage. The carbon credit is uniquely serialised, issued, tracked and retired or administratively cancelled by means of an electronic registry operated by an administrative body, such as a carbon-crediting program. revenues are the decisive element in overcoming each identified barrier; AND
      3. to demonstrate that at least one other alternative to the mitigation activity does not face significant barriers, including the barriers faced by the mitigation activity;
    3. that the evidence used shall be applied conservatively. In case of uncertainty in the level of the identified barrier, the evidence or the value shall be interpreted to assure that it is very unlikely15 that the effect of the barrier is overestimated. Such evidence may include independent studies, publicly available surveys, relevant market data, or data from national or international statistics;
    4. that all elements of the barrier analysis are assessed as part of the validationThe process of independent, third-party evaluation of a mitigation activity requesting registration under a carbon-crediting program by an accredited Validation and Verification Body (VVB) against the program provisions of the applicable carbon-crediting program. by a VVB and/or the carbon-crediting program.
  2. Where a carbon-crediting program considers that its alternative additionality approaches meet the same threshold of additionality as achieved by the requirements above in relation to one or more Categories it may, per section 3 of the Assessment Procedure, submit an explanation of such and all relevant provisions to the ICVCM and shall make such explanation publicly available.

Footnotes

  1. 15

    The term very unlikely is used per IPCC (zero to ten percent probability) and how it defines confidence levels, and to the extent any multi-stakeholder working group assesses a Category against this requirement, the assessment would be guided by the IPCC usage.

    ↩

Instruments

No instruments have been issued on this item yet.