Permanence
The GHG emission reductions or removals from the mitigation activityAn activity that reduces anthropogenic emissions of a GHG or enhances removals by sinks relative to GHG emissions or removals in the activity’s baseline scenario and seeks registration and issuance of carbon credits under a carbon-crediting program. The term refers to activities that may be implemented at different scales, including projects, programmatic approaches, policies, jurisdictional REDD+ programs, and other interventions. They may also be implemented at one or more sites. shall be permanent or, where there is a risk of reversal, there shall be measures in place to address those risks and compensate for reversals.
- The CORSIAThe Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation, a global GHG emissions reduction program developed by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) to address the CO2 emissions of international air travel. requirements relating to permanence19 shall be met.
- The following Categories of mitigation activityAn activity that reduces anthropogenic emissions of a GHG or enhances removals by sinks relative to GHG emissions or removals in the activity’s baseline scenario and seeks registration and issuance of carbon credits under a carbon-crediting program. The term refers to activities that may be implemented at different scales, including projects, programmatic approaches, policies, jurisdictional REDD+ programs, and other interventions. They may also be implemented at one or more sites. are considered to have a material risk of reversal. Carbon credits issued for mitigation activities in the Categories below may only be CCP-ApprovedCategories of carbon credits deemed approved pursuant to the Category-level assessment. Such credits may be tagged by CCP-Eligible programs. if all the requirements in criteria 9.2 to 9.5 related to permanence are met:
- storage and protection of carbon in biogenic reservoirs, including:
- conservation and avoided conversion (e.g., grassland/rangeland management, avoided deforestation);
- agriculture soil carbon sequestration;
- forestry sequestration (improved forest management, afforestation/reforestation, agroforestry);
- wetland and marine ecosystem restoration/management (including seagrasses, saltmarshes, mangroves, peatlands).
- storage and protection of carbon in biogenic reservoirs, including:
- The carbon-crediting programA standard-setting program that registers mitigation activities and issues carbon credits. shall assess the risk of reversals and where material risk is identified, have appropriate measures to avoid material risks of reversals for the following Categories:
- mitigation activities involving the displacement of non-renewable biomass;
- biochar;
- CCS with geological storage;
- enhanced weathering;
- CCS with mineralization;
- CO2 in concrete utilization.
- Jurisdictional REDD+ Programs shall be required to meet only the requirements for permanence set out in criterion 9.5 below.
- The carbon-crediting programA standard-setting program that registers mitigation activities and issues carbon credits. shall cancel a carbon creditA tradeable intangible instrument that is issued by a carbon-crediting program, representing a GHG emission reduction to, or removal from, the atmosphere equivalent to one metric tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent. This is calculated as the difference in GHG emissions or removals from a baseline scenario to the emissions or removals occurring under the mitigation activity, and any adjustments for leakage. The carbon credit is uniquely serialised, issued, tracked and retired or administratively cancelled by means of an electronic registry operated by an administrative body, such as a carbon-crediting program. for each tonne of CO2 equivalent reversed. OR
- The carbon-crediting program shall require the mitigation activityAn activity that reduces anthropogenic emissions of a GHG or enhances removals by sinks relative to GHG emissions or removals in the activity’s baseline scenario and seeks registration and issuance of carbon credits under a carbon-crediting program. The term refers to activities that may be implemented at different scales, including projects, programmatic approaches, policies, jurisdictional REDD+ programs, and other interventions. They may also be implemented at one or more sites. proponents to cancel a carbon credit for each tonne of CO2 equivalent reversed.
- The carbon-crediting programA standard-setting program that registers mitigation activities and issues carbon credits. shall in relation to Categories listed in criterion 9.1 b) 1) above:
- require a monitoring and compensation period for such mitigation activities of at least forty years from the start of the first crediting periodThe period in which verified GHG emission reductions or removals attributable to a mitigation activity can result in the issuance of carbon credits. or to at least the end of the crediting period, whichever is later;
- require mitigation activityAn activity that reduces anthropogenic emissions of a GHG or enhances removals by sinks relative to GHG emissions or removals in the activity’s baseline scenario and seeks registration and issuance of carbon credits under a carbon-crediting program. The term refers to activities that may be implemented at different scales, including projects, programmatic approaches, policies, jurisdictional REDD+ programs, and other interventions. They may also be implemented at one or more sites. proponents20 to monitor and report any reversals for the full monitoring and compensation period and compensate for avoidable reversals;
- refrain from issuing further carbon credits until avoidable reversals have been compensated;
- draw upon the pooled buffer reserve if avoidable reversals are not compensated per a) 2) above;
- treat cessation of monitoring and verificationThe process of periodic independent, third-party ex-post evaluation by a VVB of requests by a registered mitigation activity to issue carbon credits against the program provisions of the applicable carbon-crediting program. as an avoidable reversal.
- The carbon-crediting programA standard-setting program that registers mitigation activities and issues carbon credits. shall, in relation to Categories listed in criterion 9.1 b) 1) above:
- require estimation of the reversal risk using a clearly defined methodology that is made publicly available;
- require or incentivise mitigation activityAn activity that reduces anthropogenic emissions of a GHG or enhances removals by sinks relative to GHG emissions or removals in the activity’s baseline scenario and seeks registration and issuance of carbon credits under a carbon-crediting program. The term refers to activities that may be implemented at different scales, including projects, programmatic approaches, policies, jurisdictional REDD+ programs, and other interventions. They may also be implemented at one or more sites. proponents to take measures to mitigate potential reversal risks;
- define and apply clear criteria for determining whether a reversal is avoidable or unavoidable;
- implement a pooled buffer reserve to compensate for reversals to which all relevant mitigation activities contribute, and from which reversals from any contributing mitigation activities may be compensated (in order to meet the requirements of criterion 9.2);
- with respect to the pooled buffer reserve:
- ensure that the proportion of carbon credits placed in the pooled buffer reserve are at least twenty percent of the total carbon credits issued to contributing mitigation activities; OR
- ensure that the carbon credits placed in the pooled buffer reserve are proportional to the reversal risk of the mitigation activity over the full length of the monitoring and compensation period and account for the risk that the mitigation activity proponents do not compensate for avoidable reversals; AND
- make publicly available information on the pooled buffer reserve contents, including origin of carbon credits (e.g., mitigation activity, activity type and vintageThe calendar year in which the emission reduction or removal associated with a carbon credit took place. Because the verification process is conducted after the emission reductions or removals have occurred, carbon-crediting programs may issue carbon credits after the vintage year.).
- In relation to a Jurisdictional REDD+ ProgramA type of mitigation activity which is implemented by a Jurisdictional REDD+ Program Proponent and for which emission reductions and removals are quantified at the scale of a national or sub-national jurisdiction (the REDD+ Jurisdiction). Such programs may include multiple
mitigation actions in the forestry sector, including the sustainable management of forests and the conservation and enhancement of forest carbon stocks. They may include multiple actors, including governmental authorities and/or non-state actors., the carbon-crediting programA standard-setting program that registers mitigation activities and issues carbon credits. shall:
- implement a pooled buffer reserve to which each participating Jurisdictional REDD+ Program proponentA form of mitigation activity proponent that seeks the registration of a Jurisdictional REDD+ Program with a carbon-crediting program. This is a public entity or authority. See also MITIGATION ACTIVITY PROPONENT. shall contribute and from which reversals that occur within the accounting boundaries of the Jurisdictional REDD+ Program while the Jurisdictional REDD+ Program proponent is participating in the carbon-crediting program may be compensated;
- require that the percentage of carbon credits that a Jurisdictional REDD+ Program proponent must place into the pooled buffer reserve is proportional to the reversal risk and adequate to compensate for potential reversals for a minimum of forty years from the start of the first crediting periodThe period in which verified GHG emission reductions or removals attributable to a mitigation activity can result in the issuance of carbon credits.;
- where a reversal exceeds the total contribution to the pooled buffer reserve made by the relevant Jurisdictional REDD+ Program proponent prior to the reversal, require the participating Jurisdictional REDD+ Program proponent to replenish the pooled buffer reserve to return the pooled buffer reserve to a percentage proportionate to the risk per 9.5 a) 2) above;
- require that all the carbon credits in the pooled buffer reserve contributed by that Jurisdictional REDD+ Program proponent be immediately cancelled when that Jurisdictional REDD+ Program proponent leaves the carbon-crediting program;
- provide evidence to support 9.5 a) 2) above.
| Threshold | Requirements |
| In relation to permanence | The ICVCM will consider longer monitoring and compensation periods (e.g., one hundred years) and shifting the monitoring and compensation oversight to the carbon-crediting programA standard-setting program that registers mitigation activities and issues carbon credits. or the jurisdictionThe administrative unit such as a nation, state, province, region, department or district, or an ecoregion or other defined area, specified in the jurisdictional program description. aligned with existing and emerging best practice among carbon crediting programs. Given the relative newness of Jurisdictional REDD+ approaches and the lack of experience with jurisdictional programs to date, the ICVCM will continue to analyse the adequacy of the Jurisdictional REDD+ permanence criteria and consider specific criteria related to permanence for future iterations of the Assessment Framework.21 |
| In relation to criterion 9.4 | In the next iteration of the Assessment Framework, the ICVCM will require the carbon-crediting program to have provisions in place to ensure the continued operation of the pooled buffer reserve until the latest date of expiry of the monitoring and compensation period of all registered and completed mitigation activities. This may be, for example, when the carbon crediting program ceases to exist or is otherwise prevented from operating the pooled buffer reserve. |
Footnotes
-
19
↩
CORSIA “Eligibility Criterion”, “Permanence – Carbon offset credits must represent emissions reductions, avoidance, or carbon sequestration that are permanent. If there is risk of reductions or removals being reversed, then either (a) such credits are not eligible or (b) mitigation measures are in place to monitor, mitigate, and compensate any material incidence of non-permanence”.
-
20
↩
Or the carbon-crediting program or host country, if applicable.
-
21
↩
Note also the Continuous Improvement Work Program on permanence.